Best Pizza in Steubenville

Italian Food with an Attitude!

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

White Pizza (10'')

Buffalo Chicken Pizza (10'')

Our fresh dough topped with EVOO, garlic and our classic buffalo sauce blend, provonello cheese chicken breast tossed in our sauce and topped with Cheddar cheese. Drizzled with buffalo sauce and our creamy ranch dressing

Chicken Bianco Pizza (Regular 10'')

6 Slices

Calzone Big Tony

Bold Italian Taste!

Bold Italian Taste!
Indulge in the irresistible taste of our fresh dough, crafted with a unique blend of premium local and imported Italian flour. Our wood-fired oven gives it a perfectly crispy texture that's sure to delight your taste buds. Discover the bold flavors of Italy infused with the spirit of the New World, perfectly suited for the modern palate.

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
At our establishment, we prioritize quality above all else. We carefully select and invest in only the finest ingredients to ensure that every dish we serve is bursting with exceptional flavor. Our commitment to excellence stems from our belief that our customers deserve nothing but the very best.

Made With Love

Made With Love
Each member of our team is deeply passionate about providing you with an unforgettable experience, from the moment you walk through our doors to the final farewell. It's this dedication that drives us to go above and beyond to ensure that your time with us is nothing short of exceptional.
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

My wife and I got a pepperoni pizza, a white pizza, and an order of breadsticks. The breadsticks are very unique and flavorful. Everything was delicious and the staff were super friendly to us. We will DEFINITELY be back.

Jim M.

Jim M.

So glad we ordered! Really great food. Awesome workers! We tried the pizza, breadsticks and a meatball sub. My daughter who is the pickiest eater on the planet LOVED the breadsticks!! Keep up the good work! We will see you again soon!

Julia J.

Julia J.

One of the best pizzas in the valley. Good service, food comes quickly. Definitely, this place is a blessing for Steubenville. God bless you guys and keep up the good work!

Ed P.

Ed P.

I got a calzone and it was delish! The food we got was great and the girl who waited on us was very nice!

Judi P.

Judi P.

Martoni's Fire Baked Pizza Rewards

Martoni's Fire Baked Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Bold Italian Taste from the New World for the New Age!

Bold Italian Taste from the New World for the New Age!
Martoni's Fire Baked Pizza is one of the finest restaurant in OH. We not only offer amazing pizza but also serve it in a pleasant atmosphere that'll have you coming back for more. Our talented, experienced chefs create amazing dishes using fresh ingredients and traditional Italian recipes. Exotic sauces and flavors intermingle on your plate, and the hot, tangy aromas waft up to meet your nose, creating an exciting taste journey you can experience only in our restaurant.

Featuring

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Vegan Options

Frequently asked questions

Our location